We read banned books.

Posted by Unknown on Tuesday, September 24, 2013. Filed under:


This week is Banned Books Week - an annual event celebrating our freedom to read and the importance of open access to information. Books are challenged (an attempt to remove or restrict the material) or banned (an actual removal) for a variety of reasons - but they're all forms of censorship. We don't approve.

We were fortunate that when we were growing up, we could read whatever we wanted. Mom never discouraged us from reading and bought us or recommended to us many of the books below.

In honor of Banned Books Week, we put together a list of some of our favorite challenged or banned books - and the reasons why they made the list.




Eleanor & Park

Why it's challenged: Challenged this year as optional summer reading in the Anoka-Hennepin School District 11 in Minnesota by a local group called the Parents Action League who complained it included, "extreme profanity and age-inappropriate subject matter that should never be put into the hands and minds of minor children".Why we love it: Eleanor & Park is a beautiful story about two kids who feel lost in high school. The deck is stacked against them. And yet, they find each other and that relationship makes both of them stronger. Rowell pointed out in a recent interview that the ugly things the book is being challenged for aren't what the main characters are doing, it's what they're facing and trying to overcome. I thought she said it best, explaining, "When these people call Eleanor & Park an obscene story, I feel like they’re saying that rising above your situation isn’t possible. That if you grow up in an ugly situation, your story isn't even fit for good people’s ears. That ugly things cancel out everything beautiful."




Harry Potter
Why it's challenged: It was the most challenged book of the decade running 2000-2009. The most frequent reason was that it portrayed satanism or occultism.
Why we love it:  First of all, we don't get satanism out of it - to us, it's a story of love and friendship. Aside from that, though, this is our favorite get-lost-in-a-book series. It's magical.





The Kite Runner
Why it's challenged: Challenged as optional reading in the tenth-grade honors class at Troy, Pa. area schools in 2012 because the novel depicts a rape in graphic detail and uses vulgar language.
Why we love it: Yes, that scene is horrifying - but that's the point. You should be horrified by it. It help paints a broader picture of the setting in which the book is taking place.




Goosebumps
Why it's challenged: Frequently challenged for it's "extreme violence" and "occult or satanic themes".
Why we love it: We grew up on these books. Did they sometimes freak us out? Sure. Have they turned us into violent adults? No way. For us, these were the gateway to Stephen King!




To Kill a Mockingbird

Why it's banned: Removed from the St. Edmund Campion Secondary School classrooms in Brampton, Ontario, Canada in 2009 because a parent objected to language used in the novel, including the word “nigger".
Why we love it: This book is about so much more than a few bad words.




The Face on the Milk Carton
Why it's challenge: This has been in the list of the top 100 challenged books for the last two decades. It's been challenged for "sexual content", "challenge to authority" and "inappropriate for age group".
Why we love it: This is another one we grew up loving. 





Looking For Alaska
Why it's banned: Banned as required reading for Sumner County, Tenn. schools in 2012 because of “inappropriate language.”
Why we love it: This book is a little heavy, but it's also, from my own experience, not things that teenagers can avoid. We think it's incredibly beneficial for everyone to have access to books that are similar to what they're dealing with.





The Awakening

Why it's challenged: Challenged at the Oconee County, Ga. Library in 2011 because the cover of the book shows a painting of a woman’s bare chest and upset the patron. 
Why we love it: The copies I have don't contain nudity, so this really surprised me. Since this is a classic, it's been published quite a few times with quite a few covers. For this one, we're sticking with the old adage  "Never judge a book by it's cover".


The Glass Castle
Why it's challenged: Challenged, but retained as part of the tenth-grade English curriculum in the Sade-Central City High School classrooms in Cairnbrook, Pa. in 2012. The memoir in which Walls describes her hardscrabble upbringing includes sexual assault, casual profanity, drunkenness, seeing the family cat pitched from a moving car, and having to drink ditch water.
Why we love it: This was an amazing powerful memoir. Rainbow Rowell's quote above applies here, too.




The Hunger Games
Why it's challenged: Challenged and presented to the Goffstown, N.H. school board in 2010 by a parent claiming that it  gave her eleven-year-old nightmares and could numb other students to the effects of violence
Why we love it: To us, this falls into the same category of Harry Potter - it seems most people have read and enjoyed it. Yes, it may be too violent for some people, but that doesn't mean the book should be restricted for all.

What banned or challenged books are you reading this week?

No Responses to We read banned books.

Leave a Reply